What’s Inside: In this article, I provide a comprehensive AeroGarden comparison. I compare the various AeroGarden models, and I include an AeroGarden comparison chart so you can easily digest the information. I also share with you my personal experience with various AeroGarden models, and give you the inside scoop on which model I’d choose if I could only buy one AeroGarden.

Getting started with indoor gardening can seem daunting, especially for those of us who don’t consider ourselves particularly green-thumbed. But what if there was a way to cultivate your own indoor vegetable garden with ease? Enter Aerogarden, the answer to your indoor gardening dreams. But with so many models, how do you choose the right one? That’s where this AeroGarden comparison comes in handy.

In this guide, we’ll explore and compare different Aerogarden models, breaking down their features, benefits, and who they’re best suited for. Whether you live in a small apartment or simply want to enjoy fresh vegetables year-round, this AeroGarden comparison will help you find the perfect model to make your indoor gardening goals a reality, regardless of your gardening experience. Let’s get growing!

Warning

AeroGardens are addictive! Like most people, I started with one, and I now have more than 20. I’ll bet you can’t stop with just one! (Don’t say I didn’t warn you!) But seriously, keep reading to find your gateway garden of choice. You can always buy more later! 🙂

AeroGarden Comparison Guide

This article includes affiliate links.

Without further ado, let’s dive into this AeroGarden comparison, so you’ll know which AeroGarden model is right for you.

AeroGarden Comparison

AeroGarden Comparison, Pros and Cons of Different Models

Now we’ll get into our AeroGarden model comparison, along with the pros and cons of each model.

1. AeroGarden Sprout

The AeroGarden Sprout is an excellent choice for those considering their first AeroGarden. As a compact, sleek, and modern hydroponic system, it fits comfortably on your countertop, making it perfect for smaller spaces. Despite its size, you can grow quite a bit in an AeroGarden Sprout. It comes with easy-to-follow instructions, making getting started a breeze.

The Sprout can house up to three plants that can grow up to 10 inches tall, making it ideal for growing herbs or small vegetables. It features automatic LED grow lights providing optimal lighting conditions for your plants. Moreover, it’s easy to move and clean, making it a convenient option for beginners.

But what truly sets the AeroGarden Sprout apart is its affordability. It offers a cost-effective way to venture into indoor gardening. So, if you’re looking to dip your toes into the world of AeroGardens, the Sprout is a great place to start.

Pros and Cons

  • Easy to Use. Uncomplicated setup and operation
  • Compact Size. It takes up very little counter space
  • Inexpensive. No need to break the bank!
  • Limited Capacity, with space for only three plants
  • Height Limitations. Plants can grow up to 10″ max
  • Weaker Grow Lights compared to other models

2. AeroGarden Harvest

The AeroGarden Harvest is the most popular of all of the AeroGarden models, for good reason. It has room for up to 6 plants (twice as many as the Sprout), and up to 12″ of grow height. While that 2 extra inches of grow height compared to the Sprout may not seem like much, it really helps! With aggressive pruning, you can even grow peppers, tomatoes, and more, not to mention delicious greens and herbs. If you’re only going to buy one AeroGarden, and have limited funds to spend, the Harvest is a good choice.

Pros and Cons

  • Compact design, easily fits on most countertops
  • Room for 6 plants, twice as much as the Sprout
  • 20W LED light – twice as strong as the Sprout
  • Tomatoes and peppers require aggressive pruning

3. AeroGarden Harvest Elite

The AeroGarden Harvest Elite is very similar to the AeroGarden Harvest, with a few additional features. Some of those features are cosmetic, such as the stainless steel finish compared to the plastic finish on the Harvest Basic. It also more programming options compared to the basic Harvest. For instance, you can schedule the lights to come on at a specific time, compared to the basic model that comes on based on the time that you initially plug it in. The bottom line is both Harvest models are excellent choices.

Pros and Cons

  • Attractive design
  • More programming options than the Harvest Basic
  • Twice as much grow space as the Sprout
  • 12″ of grow height requires aggressive pruning for many plants.

4. AeroGarden Harvest XL

The AeroGarden Harvest XL is a pretty recent addition to the AeroGarden Harvest family. The “XL” aspect of it is that it adds 6 additional inches of grow height compared to the other Harvest models, and when you’re growing peppers and other tall plants, the extra height really helps. While, like other Harvest models, it has room for 6 plants, the grow deck is larger, so the plant pods are more spread out. This provides more room for the plants to grow not just in height, but in width. Because of that, you may have a greater yield in a Harvest XL compared to a Harvest.

Pros and Cons

  • 25W LED grow light, 5W more than the Harvest
  • 18″ of grow height, 6″ more than the Harvest
  • A larger grow deck than the Harvest
  • Limited plant size compared to the Bounty and Farm models

5. AeroGarden Bounty Basic

The AeroGarden Bounty is a big step up compared to the Harvest and Sprout models. It has room for up to 9 plants, and 24″ of grow height. I’ve grown large plants such as poblano peppers and ground cherries in a Bounty that would have been possible but challenging even in the Harvest XL.

Pros and Cons

  • Enough grow height to grow tall plants
  • Room for up to 9 plants
  • 30W LED grow lights – 10W more than the Harvest
  • Largest water bowl of all countertop gardens
  • Difficult to take apart to clean

6. AeroGarden Bounty Elite

The AeroGarden Bounty Elite is a step up from the Bounty Basic. The size is the same, but the basin has a stainless steel finish, which gives it a more classy look. It also has a 50W grow light, 20W more than the Bounty Basic, which can lead to a greater yield on fruiting plants such as cucumbers. The bottom line is that you can grow cucumbers in any Bounty model, but if you want to produce at a higher level, the stronger grow light in the Bounty Elite helps.

Pros and Cons

  • Attractive design
  • Enough room for large plants such as eggplant
  • Stronger grow light, which results in greater yield
  • More programming options than the Bounty Basic
  • Difficult to clean

7. AeroGarden Farm 12XL

The AeroGarden Farm family is for serious growers. If you have the budget for it, the AeroGarden Farm 12XL is a great place to start. I like that it is half the width of the Farm 24XL (covered below), and because of that, it’s easier to fit into a smaller space, but provides the height to be able to grow taller pepper, tomato, and other plants. With 36″ of growth height, you can even grow some varieties of slicing tomatoes, something that simply isn’t possible in smaller AeroGarden models.

Pros and Cons

  • Up to 36″ in grow height
  • Only takes up 1 square feet of space
  • Wi-Fi enabled
  • Room for up to 12 plants
  • 60W LED grow light – great for fruiting plants
  • Stackable, so you can grow more in less space
  • Too big for a countertop

7. AeroGarden Farm 24Plus

The AeroGarden Farm 24Plus is a good option for those who want to grow a lot of food in a relatively small space. With room for 24 plants, it can produce far more than models with a smaller number of pods. It offers up to 24″ of grow height. The garden has two sides, with 12 pods on each side. Each side has its own grow lights, so you can adjust the grow lights individually, based on the height of the plants you’re growing.

Pros and Cons

  • Up to 24″ in grow height
  • Room for 24 plants
  • Two adjustable 60W grow lights
  • Wi-Fi enabled
  • Stackable, so you can grow more in a small space
  • Takes up more floor space than the Farm 12XL
  • Too big for countertops
  • The plant height is 12″ less than the Farm XL models

7. AeroGarden Farm 24XL

I recently bought my first AeroGarden Farm 24XL, and let me tell you, this thing is huge! I can now finally grow slicing tomatoes on one side, and peppers, cucumbers, or other tall plants on the other side. This garden is the largest of all AeroGardens, so if you really want to take your indoor vegetable growing to a new level, this is the one for you. Out of all of the indoor gardens on the market, this one has the potential to grow the largest plants, so it’s great if you want to go beyond growing lettuce, herbs, and small fruiting plants.

Pros and Cons

  • The largest of all AeroGarden models
  • Room for up to 24 plants
  • Two 60W LED Grow lights
  • Wi-Fi enabled
  • Stackable so you can grow more food in the same footprint
  • Large footprint
  • The most expensive AeroGarden model

AeroGarden Comparison Chart

Here’s a quick overview of the various AeroGarden models. Use it to compare AeroGarden models to help you choose which one is best for you.

ModelCapacityMaximum Plant HeightLightingControl PanelAdditional Info
AeroGarden Sprout3 plants10″10W LEDNo control panel
AeroGarden Harvest6 plants12″20W LEDBasic control panel
AeroGarden Harvest Elite6 plants12″20W LEDMore advanced control panel compared to the basicAttractive stainless steel finish
AeroGarden Harvest XL6 plants18″25W LEDBasic control panelLarger grow deck compared to the other Harvest models, which provides more room for plants to grow.
AeroGarden Bounty9 plants24″30W LEDHigh resolution black and white displayLarger water basin than the Harvest and Sprout models, vacation mode
AeroGarden Bounty Elite9 plants24″50W LEDFull color touchscreenAttractive stainless steel finish, vacation mode, sunrise/sunset lighting, plus dimming grow lights
AeroGarden Farm 12XL12 plants36″60W LEDTouchscreen with Wi-FiCustomizable lighting system, stackable
AeroGarden Farm 24Plus24 plants24″60W LEDTouchscreen with Wi-FiCustomizable lighting system, stackable
AeroGarden Farm 24XL24 plants36″60W LEDTouchscreen with Wi-FiCustomizable lighting system, stackable

AeroGarden Comparison: My Personal Experience and Recommendations

I know that even with AeroGarden models compared, it can be hard to make a decision regarding which AeroGarden is best for you. My hope is that by sharing my personal experience and recommendations, you’ll be able to make the right decision.

I have personal experience with the following AeroGarden models, all available on Amazon:

My Least Favorite AeroGarden

Out of the above, the one that I like the least is the AeroGarden Sprout. It is a great beginner model, but with only 10″ of grow height, and a 10W LED grow light, it’s much more limited than the other models. As an example, while you can grow some varieties of cherry tomatoes, I’ve found that they grow slower and produce less when I grow them in the Sprout compared to a Harvest. Having said that, if you primarily want to grow lettuce and other greens, or you just want to dip your toe into using AeroGardens, and have a limited budget and space, the Sprout is a fine way to start.

My Top AeroGarden Recommendation

I was super excited when AeroGarden came out with the Harvest XL (Amazon). It’s really the perfect size for both functionality and ease of use. If I could only buy one AeroGarden model for the rest of my life, this is the one I’d choose.

If I only had the option to buy ONE AeroGarden, it would be the AeroGarden HarvestXL. There are multiple reasons for this.

First, in general, the whole AeroGarden Harvest line is the most popular option, for good reason. You can grow a wide variety of vegetables in any of the Harvest models, and yet they are reasonably priced, and easy to care for.

AeroGarden model comparison

But the AeroGarden HarvestXL adds just a bit extra compared to the other AeroGarden Harvest models. For instance, while all AeroGarden Harvest models have room for 6 plants, as you can see in the image above, the grow deck is a bit larger on the Harvest XL compared to the Harvest. Also, the grow light is 5W stronger in the Harvest XL compared to the Harvest.

AeroGarden comparions, Harvest Vs. Harvest XL
A side-by-side comparison of the AeroGarden Harvest XL on the left, and the Harvest Basic, on the right. You can see how much bigger the Harvest XL is, and yet it is still easy handle and doesn’t take up too much counterspace.

But the biggest reason that I prefer the Harvest XL compared to the Harvest is the 6 extra inches of grow height. 18″ instead of 12″ of grow height makes all the difference in the world when it comes to what you can grow, or how much you can grow of the same plant. For instance, you can grow jalapeno peppers in all Harvest models, but the 6 extra inches of grow height in the Harvest XL means less pruning, and ultimately more fruit.

AeroGarden comparison - Green beans growing in an AeroGarden Harvest XL
Growing green beans in an AeroGarden HarvestXL – they were small at this point, but as they grew, the extra height compared to the Harvest really helped!

In addition to that, the Harvest XL, while larger than the other Harvest models, is still very easy to handle. I can pick up and move the Harvest XL even when it’s full of water, but I struggle to do the same with the Bounty models. The Harvest XL is the sweet spot between grow height, and ease of use. It’s also easier to clean than the Bounty models, which I really struggle with.

The Top 3 AeroGarden Models

If you only buy one AeroGarden model, I recommend either the Harvest, or Harvest XL. My third choice is the Bounty, since you can grow larger plants in it compared to any of the Harvest models.

AeroGarden Comparison Conclusion

Navigating the world of indoor gardening can be a little overwhelming, especially when you’re just starting out. But don’t let that deter you! With our comprehensive AeroGarden comparison, we hope to have made your journey a bit smoother. Remember, the best AeroGarden model for you largely depends on your individual needs, space constraints, and gardening goals.

As you embark on this exciting journey to grow your own indoor garden, remember that every gardener learns as they grow. So, whether you’re growing aromatic herbs, vibrant flowers, or fresh vegetables, each AeroGarden model offers a unique way to bring your indoor gardening dreams to life.

If you enjoyed this article, you will enjoy these related articles:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *